Skip to content
Home » Blog » Peat-free composts in Saltash

Peat-free composts in Saltash

Peat-based composts will  be banned from 2024. But we can’t wait till then, we have to act now. Digging up peat releases huge amounts of greenhouse gas every year.

I’ve been trying peat-free composts for years, and found them really difficult to use – but the newest one are much improved

Peat is the UK’s tropical rainforest

Peat is dug out of our peat bogs –

  • Peat bogs are a fantastic habitat, home to several unique species
  • At least half the weight of peat is carbon, like the trees in tropical rainforest. Digging it up dries it out, and releases that carbon as carbon dioxide, the main greenhouse gas
  • Globally, more carbon is stored in peat bogs than in tropical rainforests!
  • Peat bogs absorb rainwater and reduce flooding

Most of the garden peat sold today is dug from European peat bogs, as we have drained almost all of our own in the UK – how dishonest is that!!

If we don’t make this change to peat-free compost, we have no moral right to think bad thoughts about anyone (like Bolsonaro) who destroys rainforests in other parts of the world.

I searched the web for articles defending peat – there’s usually some vested interest arguing against the eco movement – but couldn’t find any. That in itself says something: all good.  

Is peat-free easy to use?

Peat-free is a little challenging, as it’s different from using peat-based.

In 2020, I was very impressed with Sylva All-Purpose from Tamar Nurseries – the first one that’s ever impressed me! Both RHS and Which? report good results with it. I mixed it with soil and with home-made compost.

But sadly, the nursery didn’t sell enough of it in 2020, so aren’t stocking it. I haven’t found it anywhere in Saltash. I bought something else (name of Happy) thinking it was compost  but when I read the small print it was soil conditioner (feeling of Sad).

I’ve recently discovered Miracle-Gro peat-free in Coop at a very competitive price (£6 for 50 Li). It’s fluffy and my first reaction is – I like it!

Sylva

Why did we ever use peat?

Yes, why indeed. In the 1960s, they peat holds air, water and nutrients and releases them at just the right rates for best growth. It was fairly lightweight and clean for handling. This transformed the nursery industry. 

The practical things that can be said against peat are that

  • if it dries out it can be very difficult to rewet
  • it degrades over time into a useless, inert brown powder
  • and
  • using it destroys our Planet.

Why do we continue to buy peat-based compost?

It could be any one or more of 5 motives! We need to recognise 3 of them for just what they are – 3 excuses: “I always buy it, every year; I find it easier to choose than peat-free; and I wasn’t aware of the environmental cost”.

But we need to understand 2 other motives: “Peat-free composts are more expensive; and they are difficult to use”. It’s true that they can cost a little more, (up to £2 per bag for Sylva) but as soon as we buy more of them, they’ll become competitive. It’s also true that the best of them are now (2021) very much improved.

New horizon

Coping with peat-free substitutes

They all combine different materials, so use with care.  Plenty of advice is available, for example Which?
Website and RHS https://www.rhs.org.uk/advice/profile?pid=441

  • Peat-free can hold more water than peat-based – if pots look dry, thee may still be plenty of water at the roots
  • Plants may need feeding a bit more often than with peat, maybe every 3-4 weeks
  • Check the bag for instructions – boring but important
  • There is no real peat-free ‘all purpose’  yet – be prepared to make your own mix by adding grit, home-made compost, fertiliser etc.

Getting the peat-free habit

  • Defo look for the words ‘peat-free’ – be very aware of words like ‘environmentally friendly’, ‘compost’ and ‘organic’ they are not the same thing
  • It might be a little more expensive than peat-based
  • Check you got the right one (seed sowing, growing on, containers)
  • Tell everyone else to go peat-free

The best-performing peat-frees in trials by Which? and RHS for different uses are:

  • Seeds: Sylva, or Westland New Horizon (in Tamar and Coop and about the same cost as peat-based)
  • Growing on: Sylva
  • Containers: Homebase peat-free (and much cheaper at 11p per litre)
  • Ericaceous: Sylva-grow.

Why not mention these names to Tamar View Nurseries?

We’ll write a blog on buying plants that have been grown in peat-free compost as soon as we can

Adrian White May 2021